- Grower Manager Fresh Produce
- Senior Commercial Manager (Sales and Procurement)
- Packing Supervisor
- Head Grower Greenhouse Canada
- Post Entry Quarantine Facility Manager
- Economic Policy Officer Agri-Tech Kentucky
- Licensing Manager North America
- Junior Sales Executive
- Fruit Breeder/Trait Discovery Scientist
- General Manager
Top 5 -yesterday
Top 5 -last week
Top 5 -last month
- Combining vertical farming and greenhouse horticulture to decentralize lettuce production
- Mexico: Rising Farms boosts capacity fivefold
- Higher light transmission and lower heat demand with double foil greenhouse
- Fresh produce chain hit by Lakeside Produce’s bankruptcy
- Conventional and organic: greenhouse grower does it all
guest post by Tinia Pina:
The classification gap of organic hydroponic food
According to the memo, “The framework of organic farming is based on its foundation of sound management of soil biology and ecology.” Modern organic farming thus entails the “continuous restoration” of soil by adding combinations of manure, compost and natural rock to feed the soil, not the crops. In contrast, hydroponic crops use a soilless substrate such as rockwool, coco coir, hydrocorn, perlite or vermiculite, as the bed for seeds or seedlings. By definition, hydroponic crops do not use soil, and therefore the HATF and USDA found that hydroponically grown food cannot be classified as organic.
In this article, Tinia Pina, CEO and founder of Re-nuble, discusses two topics pertaining to the classification of hydroponic crops grown exclusively with products that consist of compost (or degraded organic waste) properties, and how we need further research in finding an equivalent classification to “organic” for hydroponically grown food.
Grown in the Ground – Grown in a Nutrient Solution Continuum
The definition of what’s grown in the ground and what’s grown in a nutrient solution is surprisingly difficult to parse. This is because modern day agricultural growing can happen in a variety of hybrid methods. In the chart below, we’ve visualized what the HATF named the “Grown in the Ground – Grown in a Nutrient Solution Continuum” represents. Of the five growing methods named, only the first two (from the left) can ever be certified organic. The other three methods (from the right) can never be certified organic.
As the graph above shows, there is no distinction among possible hydroponic liquid nutrient compositions. While the majority of hydroponically grown food uses inorganic inputs, there is a The Classification Gap of Organic Hydroponic Food company that produces nutrient products manufactured entirely with inputs that are organic and with biological components derived from the organic certified produce waste. Its products are liquid nutrients and crops grown would inherently undergo a process similar to crops grown with compost.
The clear delineation between this company’s nutrients and chemical nutrients thus presents a classification gap for crops grown. If all of the inputs in a hydroponic system are organic and the system uses a nutrient that incorporates a biological composting process to grow a crop, shouldn’t the yields be considered organic? Unfortunately, the findings of the HAFT did not offer further information on such a process.
What is “soil”?
Another deceptively complicated concept is defining what is considered “soil”. The HAFT report cites previous Crops Committee documents, which posed the question of whether growing media that are “predominantly compost and compostable plant materials be considered ‘soil?’”
In this context, such a question is ambiguous, because organic farming is built on the premise of nurturing soil to create “accompanying ecologies”. As the report notes, earthworms, protozoa, fungi, bacteria, antinomycetes and other soil dwelling organisms can exist in compost. Therefore, for all intents and purposes, compost is soil.
Thus, we the industry should pose the question – if composting-like processes are used to manufacture nutrients, can said hydroponic nutrients, when used in a hydroponic system, be an ecological extension of soil?
The HAFT report did say that regulations did not initially “specifically state ‘soil only production’” was required for organic certification, but that the intent of the regulations includes soil in organic certification. The 2010 findings of the OSB did mandate soil be the accepted norm, in line with European regulations. HAFT concedes, however, that standards must be added when classifying soilless growing system yields.
Why should we care?
The lack of clarity in the organic classification system for hydroponically grown food poses challenges to the indoor agriculture industry both as a threat to create a national, universal organic certification and as a threat to competitive pricing for hydroponically grown food. The demand for organic produce in the States has been on the rise for the past decade, with 2014 sales totaling USD 5.5 billion, up 72% since 2008. The “organic” certification on produce has a large and measureable value.
Ethically, we have a responsibility to our consumers. One of the main justifications of the lengthy and detailed HAFT report was to bring clarity to consumers on what constitutes “organic” products. With no equal classification to organic, those consuming hydroponically grown food – which is increasingly available across the country – have no way of knowing what their food contains.
Therefore, I propose a new system of classification for hydroponically grown food. An obvious method of classification is whether the used nutrients contain chemicals or non-plant inputs.
Knowing that there is a wide range of hydroponic growing systems, we welcome your thoughts on the issue. In the future, we hope to see the USDA explore the hydroponic “organic” classification question further.
Tinia Pina (e-mail) is the CEO and Founder of Re-Nuble.
Respond? Send us an email to share your opinion!
Receive the daily newsletter in your email for free | Click here
Other news in this sector:
- 2023-02-03 “We’re reaching a point where conventional costs more than organic”
- 2023-01-13 Retailer registration opens for Organic Produce Summit 2023
- 2022-12-16 "We aim to go entirely organic”
- 2022-12-09 Spreading the nutritional value of microgreens on a national scale after amazing flood rebuild
- 2022-11-01 Organic consumption holds up if the supply range is extended
- 2022-10-18 Organic Grower Summit 2022 announces Grower of the Year
- 2022-09-23 Texas A&M AgriLife research to improve organic spinach production
- 2022-08-09 Cost Share Organic Certification Fee application period still open
- 2022-07-07 Revamped baby leaf containers to debut at Organic Produce Summit
- 2022-02-24 Consultants in organic farming get to the heart of the matter with growers
- 2022-02-01 U.S. organic produce sales top $9 billion in 2021
- 2021-10-27 Canadian greenhouse grower expands organics program
- 2021-09-27 Organic shoppers demand sustainable packaging
- 2021-09-21 Greenhouse growers present on Organic Produce Summit
- 2021-09-16 The UK horticulture conference created by growers for growers is back!
- 2021-06-03 Booth registration opens for Organic Grower Summit
- 2021-06-01 Pinduoduo embarks on first-of-its-kind study into plant-based meats
- 2021-05-07 Organic pak choi grown in good Dutch soil
- 2021-04-26 The World Food Innovation Awards awards the Monterosa tomato as the best natural and organic product
- 2021-04-23 Strategic organic partnership carries over to upcoming show