The HFFA Research GmbH recently published a study comparing the impact of conventional farming against organic farming on biodiversity in Germany. In the following interview, Steffen Noleppa, the corresponding author of the study, talks about why organic farming is not better than conventional farming and why ideological fronts need to be broken down.
What are the main findings of your study?
We confirmed a fact that is already well known: Organic farming creates certain benefits with respect to maintaining species richness on arable land that is properly managed. However, organic farming also constitutes a substantial human intervention in natural ecosystems and already results in a considerable loss of biodiversity. In comparison, conventional farming results in little additional loss.
Can you explain that in more detail?
Biodiversity is just one goal of agricultural production but not its main goal. First of all, agriculture is charged with supplying enough food, feed, fiber, and fuel for an ever-growing world population. Within this broader view, the outcome in terms of biodiversity impact is changing. The significant yield advantage of conventional farming results in less losses of species richness per ton produced when compared to organic agriculture. According to our calculations, the loss of species richness per ton of wheat, corn, or other crop produced in organic farming in Germany is on average more than 50 percent higher than in cases where advanced and productivity-enhancing technologies are used through conventional production methods.
What are the reasons that yields are lower in organic farming than in conventional farming?
Organic farmers also use inputs to control pests and fauna that threaten their crops, for example fatty acids, salts, or natural insecticides. In addition, they use mechanical or thermal measures to control weeds, and they apply sulfur and copper compounds, for example, to minimize fungi. However, these measures are limited and usually less targeted than others. The restriction of using “natural” options leaves crops partially exposed to considerable damage, and diseases and insects cause higher yield losses. And by using only organic fertilizers, farmers are limited in meeting periods when nutrient demand of crops peaks. This lowers yields further.
What would happen if only organic farming existed?
Our various analyses have shown that conventional agriculture is not only economically viable but also saves scarce natural resources such as land and water. If we converted to organic farming completely, much more land and other resources would be needed to keep up with demand. Moreover, food prices would increase considerably.
In your study, you state that “ideologically hardened fronts must be broken down.” How can that be put into practice?
In my view, the answer is simple and complex at the same time: Increasing productivity is important – and the benefits of higher productivity (not to be confused with intensity) in agricultural production need to be highlighted time and again. However, that does not mean that we should ignore environmental or other goals. On the contrary, they need to be included in smart climate and biodiversity agricultural production schemes. To reach a societal consensus about the design of such complex production schemes, a dialog between all stakeholders – such as members of civil society, industry representatives, politicians, and scientists – is needed. This is both the challenge and the key.
Source: Bayer Food Chain Partnership






Announcements
Job Offers
- Head Grower Greenhouse Canada
- Post Entry Quarantine Facility Manager
- Economic Policy Officer Agri-Tech Kentucky
- Licensing Manager North America
- Junior Sales Executive
- Fruit Breeder/Trait Discovery Scientist
- General Manager
- Regional Sales Manager – DACH Region
- Country Manager – Italy
- Country Manager – Spain
"Tweeting Growers"
Top 5 -yesterday
Top 5 -last week
- “Black growbags could benefit vegetable crops as well”
- Latvia: First greenhouse to grow cucumbers under LEDs uses landfill waste to produce energy
- "Moisture is the big danger in the next two months"
- "Even light intensity at every spot in the greenhouse"
- US (OH): 80 Acres Farms makes layoffs as tech job crunch continues
Top 5 -last month
- How farmers are cutting out supermarkets
- Combining vertical farming and greenhouse horticulture to decentralize lettuce production
- Higher light transmission and lower heat demand with double foil greenhouse
- Fresh produce chain hit by Lakeside Produce’s bankruptcy
- 30MHz declared bankrupt, curator 'optimistic about restart'
Receive the daily newsletter in your email for free | Click here
Other news in this sector:
- 2023-01-13 Retailer registration opens for Organic Produce Summit 2023
- 2022-12-16 "We aim to go entirely organic”
- 2022-12-09 Spreading the nutritional value of microgreens on a national scale after amazing flood rebuild
- 2022-11-01 Organic consumption holds up if the supply range is extended
- 2022-10-18 Organic Grower Summit 2022 announces Grower of the Year
- 2022-09-23 Texas A&M AgriLife research to improve organic spinach production
- 2022-08-09 Cost Share Organic Certification Fee application period still open
- 2022-07-07 Revamped baby leaf containers to debut at Organic Produce Summit
- 2022-02-24 Consultants in organic farming get to the heart of the matter with growers
- 2022-02-01 U.S. organic produce sales top $9 billion in 2021
- 2021-10-27 Canadian greenhouse grower expands organics program
- 2021-09-27 Organic shoppers demand sustainable packaging
- 2021-09-21 Greenhouse growers present on Organic Produce Summit
- 2021-09-16 The UK horticulture conference created by growers for growers is back!
- 2021-06-03 Booth registration opens for Organic Grower Summit
- 2021-06-01 Pinduoduo embarks on first-of-its-kind study into plant-based meats
- 2021-05-07 Organic pak choi grown in good Dutch soil
- 2021-04-26 The World Food Innovation Awards awards the Monterosa tomato as the best natural and organic product
- 2021-04-23 Strategic organic partnership carries over to upcoming show
- 2021-04-01 "A coherent strategy for organic is essential"