Job offersmore »

Tweeting Growers

Top 5 - yesterday

  • No news has been published yesterday.

Top 5 - last week

Top 5 - last month

Exchange ratesmore »

South African parliament adopts motion for land expropriation without compensation

A day is a long time in politics: two days ago, new President Cyril Ramaphosa announced a new cabinet, appointing new ministers in the portfolios of finance, public enterprises, mineral resources and water affairs (among others). Yesterday a momentous debate on land reform in parliament led to the adoption of a motion to allow for the expropriation of land without compensation.

The motion was brought by an opposition party, the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), and was adopted by 241 votes in favour and 83 against. When a similar motion was brought a year ago it was overwhelmingly defeated.

The ANC, which unusually voted with an opposition party on this matter, introduced amendments to the motion to the effect that such land reform should occur in a manner that does not compromise food security and increases agricultural productivity.

Currently the constitution does not allow for expropriation without compensation, so a constitutional reform committee has been tasked with considering the matter and will bring it before parliament again by the end of August. Organised agriculture are largely opposed to land expropriation without compensation, fearing its impact on agricultural investment, while analysts are welcoming the debate because the land reform process up until now has not been very successful. President Ramaphosa has said that he would consult financial institutions on land reform.

During yesterday’s debate Julius Malema, leader of the EFF said: “The time for reconciliation is over, now is the time for justice. If the grandchildren of Jan van Riebeeck [Dutch commander who claimed the Cape in 1652] have not understood that we need our land back, then they have failed to receive the gift of humanity.” 

The spectre of Zimbabwe always looms large when discussing the important subject of land reform. Agricultural economists Wandile Sihlobo and Johann Kirsten wrote last week: “With the benefit of hindsight, the Zimbabwean experience tells us that the notion of expropriation without compensation is a bad idea. The Zimbabweans might have seized the land without compensation 18 years ago, but they collectively paid for it through eight consecutive years of economic decline that led to job losses, de-industrialisation and a loss of agricultural export revenues.”

Publication date: 3/7/2018



Other news in this sector:

6/22/2018 Switzerland: "We are independent, to guarantee our freedom"
6/21/2018 Mexico: Tomatoes surpass avocados and become second most exported product
6/21/2018 US: Hourly wages for hired farmworkers have grown steadily
6/20/2018 How sealed containers are broken open
6/20/2018 Global ambitions for Australian vegetable growers
6/20/2018 “Difficult Dutch tomato market, but there’s light at the end of the tunnel”
6/20/2018 US: Pricing and demand of Romaine lettuce are off
6/20/2018 US, Spain, and Mexico account for 40% of Peruvian pepper exports
6/20/2018 Spain: End of Canary tomato campaign with lower exports
6/20/2018 Annual growth in labour costs at 2.0% in euro area
6/20/2018 China: Shandong vegetable prices increase
6/20/2018 US (CA): Radicchio welcomes strong demand
6/19/2018 Canadian growers shake their heads at talk of boycotting US goods
6/18/2018 Africa: New programme to boost soil productivity, reduce soil degradation
6/15/2018 America's favourite vegetable is broccoli
6/15/2018 Modernisation creating good competition on the pepper market
6/15/2018 Guatemala: "Crops won't be harmed by the eruption of the volcano"
6/15/2018 Norwegian cucumbers are doing well
6/15/2018 US: Rain in Florida, labor shortage in California for tomato growers
6/14/2018 Demand for South Australian eggplant carrying on into winter